Oracle sues Google over Java use in Android

Analyst says that Google's "clean room," reverse-engineered Dalvik clone of Java should protect it from Oracle's claims.

Oracle has filed a lawsuit against Google, charging that its Android mobile OS infringes Oracle patents and copyrights related to Java, Oracle said on Thursday.

"In developing Android, Google knowingly, directly and repeatedly infringed Oracle's Java-related intellectual property. This lawsuit seeks appropriate remedies for their infringement," Oracle spokeswoman Karen Tillman said in a statement.

[ Stay ahead of the key tech business news with InfoWorld's Today's Headlines: First Look newsletter, and follow Java developments with our JavaWorld Enterprise Java newsletter. | Read Bill Snyder's Tech's Bottom Line blog for what the key business trends mean to you. ]

The suit was filed Thursday in U.S. District Court in San Francisco and seeks a jury trial. Google could not immediately reached for comment on the lawsuit. It was unclear Thursday if Oracle approached Google to discuss its concerns before it filed the lawsuit.

Oracle acquired Sun Microsystems' Java technology when it bought the company earlier this year. Java is a software environment that allows applications written in Java to run on virtually any computer so long as it has a Java virtual machine installed.

When Google developed Android it included a Java-compatible technology called Dalvik with the phone OS. Dalvik was developed as a "clean room" version of Java, meaning Google built it from the ground up without using any Sun technology or intellectual property, said Gartner analyst Ken Dulaney.

"You can't just take a Java application from a Sun environment, where it's licensed, and run it on Android. You have to recompile it to Dalvik," Dulaney said.

Oracle says Dalvik is a competitor to Java and infringes several of its patents, which it lists in the complaint, and its Java copyright.

Oracle's motivation was probably Android's recent success in the smartphone market, Dulaney said. "They own Sun now and they want to collect the royalties on the language," he said.

Oracle alleges that Google was aware of its patents and "willfully and deliberately" infringed them. It also says Google hired some of Sun's Java engineers. It wants the court to block the alleged infringement and award it damages.

Dulaney said Oracle's case could be "hard to prove" and that a legal battle could take a long time. "What they'll have to argue about is whether Google did a purely clean-room Java or if they have someone with inside knowledge of the code," he said.

Dalvik is one option for writing Android applications; developers can also use HTML5 and the C language. But Dalvik is used for some of the core Android applications, such as email, Dulaney said.

source